Does the Report Draft Answer the Assignment Questions?
Before handing a report draft to a reviewer, compare it with the specific documentation questions in the assignment. For each question, locate the relevant draft passage and its source, then record whether the response addresses the question, addresses only part of it, or remains unresolved. A report can contain accurate sentences and still omit something it was asked to document. A populated section heading is not evidence that the requested information is present.
This is a manual document-review method, not an automated StateClaimAI feature or a test of claim eligibility. The site's drafting standards call for source clarity, visible open items and review of file-specific requirements. Follow your organisation's authorised process; this guide does not determine coverage, liability, payment, legal obligations or any claim outcome.
Start with the actual documentation request
Identify the instruction or assignment version that the draft is meant to address. Preserve the original wording and its location. If the request is unclear, obtain clarification from the appropriate owner rather than rewriting it into an easier question and marking that new question complete.
Separate requests that require different pieces of information. For example, “Describe the locations observed and identify the source references” asks for both a description and references that can be followed. A paragraph naming the locations may address the first part while leaving the second part unanswered. Keep the parent instruction visible so the split does not change its meaning.
Limit this exercise to the documentation task you are authorised to perform. If an instruction calls for a determination outside that scope, flag it for the responsible professional. Do not turn a request for a claim decision into a writing prompt or assume a fluent answer is an acceptable substitute for professional judgment.
Build a question-to-passage map
Use a small working record alongside the draft. It need not become another report section or be uploaded to a tool. Each row should contain:
- The original documentation question, its identifier and instruction version.
- The response expected from this bounded task, without adding requirements of your own.
- The exact draft version, section and passage that attempts to answer it.
- The underlying source reference and any qualification that affects the wording.
- What is addressed, what remains missing, and the evidence needed for the next step.
- The person responsible for clarifying or reviewing the unresolved point.
A question may point to several passages. Keep those links together rather than counting each passage as a separately completed requirement. Conversely, one paragraph may contribute to several questions without fully answering all of them. Check the content against each request rather than giving the paragraph a general “complete” label.
Record factual accuracy and task completeness separately. A source-backed sentence may be accurate but insufficient for the question. A paragraph that appears to answer everything may contain an unsupported detail. Neither result should conceal the other.
Work through an invented example
All identifiers and facts below are fictional. Instruction I-2 asks a preparer to document the visible wall marks in rooms A and B, identify the related photographs, and list any location references that still require clarification. Note N-7 records a mark in room A. Note N-8 records a mark in room B. Photograph P-3 has a room label whose meaning is not yet confirmed.
Draft D-4 says: “N-7 records a visible wall mark in room A.” That sentence may faithfully represent N-7, but it does not address the whole instruction. It omits the requested room B description, gives no related photograph reference, and does not show the unresolved label on P-3. Calling the paragraph accurate would not make those omissions disappear.
The working map can distinguish three results. The requested room descriptions are partly addressed: room A has a located passage, while the source-supported room B material has not been included. The photograph relationship is unresolved: the preparer cannot connect P-3 to a room on the current evidence. The request to list open location references is not yet addressed in D-4, even though the preparer already knows that such a question exists.
A revised illustrative passage for human review could read: “N-7 records a visible wall mark in room A, and N-8 records a visible wall mark in room B. The room relationship for photograph P-3 remains unconfirmed because its label requires clarification.” This adds the available source-backed information and makes the unresolved relationship visible. It does not establish which room P-3 depicts, the cause of either mark, or any claim conclusion.
After the revision, the map should say that D-5 now includes both note descriptions and the open label question. It should still show the photograph relationship as unresolved. Naming a gap in the draft can satisfy a request to disclose open questions; it does not supply the missing answer. The assigned reviewer decides how that unresolved item affects the next authorised documentation step.
Distinguish missing prose from missing evidence
When a row has no adequate answer, first establish why. Material may already be in the authorised source packet but absent from the draft. The draft may mention it without a usable reference. The source may not contain the requested information. Or the instruction may be too ambiguous to apply. These situations call for different actions.
For a drafting omission, propose wording that remains faithful to the available source and send it through the required review. For a missing reference, locate the real source or mark the connection unresolved. For absent evidence, record the gap and the owner of the next request. For unclear instructions, ask the authorised instruction owner to clarify. Do not solve all four by adding a confident sentence.
The field-notes workflow helps organise observations, statements, photographs and open items into a draft. The question-to-passage map adds a different check: whether that particular draft addresses this particular documentation assignment. It does not replace source review, and it does not turn an unanswered question into an instruction to obtain material through an unauthorised channel.
Read in both directions before handoff
First read from the instruction to the draft. Can you locate an adequate response or an explicit, accurately described gap for each documentation question? A generic heading such as “Scene observations” is a navigation aid; read the actual passage beneath it. Avoid declaring all questions complete merely because every template section contains text.
Then read from the draft back to the instruction and sources. Look for statements that were added to make the report sound finished but are unsupported or outside the agreed task. A necessary explanation can remain if it is sourced and appropriate; do not remove useful context solely because it was not phrased as a separate question. Route questionable additions to the reviewer instead of silently expanding the assignment.
Do not convert the map into a completion percentage that hides important gaps. Three located responses out of four is a count of rows, not a measure of report readiness or professional approval. Different questions may have different significance, and the required decision belongs to the responsible reviewer.
Keep the map attached to the version it describes
When the draft changes, revisit the affected question-to-passage links. A paragraph moved to another section may need a new locator; a revised sentence may answer more or less than before. When the instruction changes, preserve the earlier mapping and record the new scope rather than making an old review appear to cover it.
Use a review handoff cover sheet to identify the packet, recipient and requested review. The question map supplies content-level evidence about what is addressed and unresolved; the cover sheet supplies the handoff context. “Mapped”, “comments received” and “professionally reviewed” are different states.
For the supported drafting workflow, open the StateClaimAI workspace and check its current access and usage conditions. Bring only authorised, necessary material and keep source references available for human review. For a product-operation question, use official support without including private claim material in an initial enquiry. Completing this working map, opening the workspace or producing a draft does not establish a claim decision or a successful business outcome.